Genetic blood testing is showing potential as a means of catching some early stage cancers, researchers are reporting.
For example, a panel of three different genetic tests was able to detect early stage lung cancer about half of the time in people who’d already been diagnosed with the disease.
The tests also detected late-stage lung cancers about 9 out of 10 times, the researchers said.
The findings were reported Saturday at the American Society of Clinical Oncology’s annual meeting, in Chicago.
“This is proof of principle that broad genome-wide sequencing has the ability to find cancer, and sometimes early stage curable cancer,” said lead study author Dr. Geoffrey Oxnard. He’s an associate professor of medicine at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute and Harvard Medical School, both in Boston.
A genetic test could provide a little more peace of mind for those worried about family history.
California-based Color Genomics does not accept insurance, but charges $249 for a 30-gene panel. The company gathers results from your saliva, although in the future it could also test blood.
Judy Hiemenga, MD, a cancer genetics specialist with Spectrum Health, said the test can be beneficial for some patients, whether to check a high-risk family history or to just alleviate worry.
She recently sat down with Health Beat to discuss the details of the genetic test. Learn more.
“That creates an opportunity for further development as a cancer detection or screening assay,” he said.
Cancer survival rates soar when tumors are detected in their earliest stages, the researchers said in background notes. Having a blood test that can detect early cancers would save countless lives.
Tumors regularly shed DNA fragments that circulate in the bloodstream. These fragments, called cell-free DNA, are already analyzed to help cancer doctors choose targeted gene-based therapies for people with advanced lung cancer, the researchers said.
Oxnard and his colleagues want to take that a step further, by developing a test that uses cell-free DNA to catch cancers as early as possible.
Their overall effort, the Circulating Cell-Free Genome Atlas (CCGA) study, has enrolled more than 12,000 of a planned 15,000 participants across the United States and Canada.
The ASCO meeting report represents some of the first results from the larger study. In it, the researchers used genetic tests to analyze the blood of 127 people who had been diagnosed with lung cancer.
The three tests looked for both cancer mutations and changes in genetic function that can indicate cancer, the researchers said.
The tests detected early stage lung cancer between 38 and 51 percent of the time, and late-stage cancers between 87 and 89 percent of the time.
The tests also had a very low rate of false positives—when a test says cancer is present when it isn’t. The researchers tested 580 blood samples from people without cancer, and found only five with genetic changes indicating cancer.
Of those five supposedly cancer-free people, two were subsequently diagnosed with stage 3 ovarian cancer and stage 2 endometrial cancer, further highlighting the potential of the tests to find early stage cancers, the researchers said.
In addition, the researchers further refined the screening process by filtering out people with harmless white blood cell mutations, Oxnard added.
“The fact is we acquire mutations as we age. Our white cells have mutations, and these mutations pollute the DNA that’s in the blood,” Oxnard said. “You have to screen out the white cell signal to end up with the leftover signal that’s in the free DNA. In that signal is where you can find the cancer signal.”
About 54 percent of mutations detected in the blood samples were from white blood cells rather than cancers, the researchers said. These will need to be filtered out of any blood tests ultimately developed for early detection of cancer.
While this study is promising, more work needs to be done to hone the blood test’s ability to detect specific cancers, said ASCO President Dr. Bruce Johnson.
For example, one of the most common mutations related to cancer is in a gene called KRAS, Johnson said.
“If you picked up KRAS in the bloodstream, you’re not sure if it came from the lung or the pancreas or the colon,” said Johnson, chief clinical research officer at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute.
“This is another step forward, but it’s not getting really close yet to being specific for being able to pick up an early cancer,” Johnson cautioned. “It’s another step forward, but it’s got a ways to go.”
Oxnard agreed that further research is needed before these genetic tests could be used by doctors, but he couldn’t say how long it might take to produce a clinically useful screening tool.
“I would have told you this study we’re talking about was years off a year ago. This is striking evidence of progress,” Oxnard said.